So… managed to end up at Toys R Us again, and bought 3 more Domez. This time there was the added bonus of them being cheaper!
I managed not to get any dupes:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/03cc2/03cc2be7f71605bf9819f38ded5086f5a35eee48" alt=""
First up, Catwoman:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3302c/3302c47cd31c255fd016a320d6b713e229266c6e" alt=""
I initially opened these up in the dark, so didn’t see the scratch on her head :(. This is the favourite of the 3 I opened, but I may have to do something about that mark… darnit.
Batman:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0822e/0822ea164fb9e0cd640d1e9adf361003f43bc2e6" alt=""
It’s… Batman. Looks OK from this angle, but the mouth makes him look a bit derpy.
Lastly, but definitely least, Superman:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a38f6/a38f6940ffd63beffc075dbdad99da3f490a9afa" alt=""
Yeah… what the heck is going on with that face?! I’m not a fan of Superman at the best of times, and this one… well. Face is super-derp and the head looks more out of proportion than the others.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d090a/d090a1a73cb72a5f6ea24cced9952fd3a6610a81" alt=""
Ah, that’s better. This angle actually looks OK! Back of his head doesn’t say “Superman” to me, but hey, I don’t have to look at that face any more.
Ignoring the scratch on Catwoman’s head, I’ve got 2 that I like, one I’m mediocre about and one that might get hidden in a drawer. Not a bad pull.